Dispensationalism: No Rest for the Weary

The wedge issue has always been Dispensational eschatology.

I came to full religious awareness while living in Anchorage, Alaska. It was about the time I turned twelve years old. My family was attending a particular Baptist church where the pastor wasn’t pushy about anything at all. Internal church politics kept him in place because he was just a figurehead; he didn’t interfere with those who had influence and an agenda. It was a relatively large church, so it was ripe for strong figures who wanted to spread their propaganda. They didn’t just show up randomly; I know for certain some of those big shots had influenced other movers and shakers to move their membership there.

One of those strong figures was a doctrinaire Scandinavian import who more than once got the church to allow him to set up displays in the fellowship hall. It was on particular evenings when the membership gathered for a fellowship meal or other festive occasion. One of those evenings he placed a large collection of posters, banners and printed pamphlets about Dispensationalism. That term wasn’t what stuck in my mind at the time; it was the phrase “End Times.”

This was the late 1960s when stuff like that was news to a lot of Baptists. I distinctly recall the initial mixed reception among the adults with whom I had any social contact. Among those with a positive reaction, it was very positive, urging me to take a copy of the most graphically illustrated pamphlet and study it. The whole thing became an on-going discussion among church members kicked off by that display.

I wasn’t aware of national politics, much less international relations, until later in high school when I was at risk for the Vietnam War draft. I don’t recall at all any kind of connection between that talk of End Times at church and the issue of Israel, but somehow I got the message. I was a full blown supporter of Zionism, insofar as I knew anything at all about it. Yet it remained in my mind two separate things for the longest time. Thus, I slowly moved away from Dispensationalism long before I realized it meant I had no reason to favor Israel politically.

Eventually, having moved a safe distance away from all of that, I was exposed to a critical review of the religious literature that promoted this stuff. I recall devouring Hal Lindsey’s Late Great Planet Earth along with a couple of later books in that series. I recall how it all seemed so real. I knew nothing of the author and his shenanigans until much later. Virtually nothing in his books ever came true, and it was part of a longstanding genre of similar literature that rested entirely on trying to fit current events into some wild speculative doctrines. It wasn’t a question of whether Lindsey believed any of that stuff; I was disturbed by the underlying cynicism of hooking my generation so he could become a millionaire. Maybe it was just instinct for him, but it remains one of the best examples of marketing manipulation in American history.

Having studied the roots of this whole Dispensational nonsense, I am struck by one consistent factor across the entire range of major figures promoting it: Every one of them had an ulterior motive. There was not a single “true believer” willing to sacrifice for the sake of conviction, except at the lower levels. The leadership of this thing have always had their eye on something else, and this was their big tool.

Worse, there has always been a background of secret dealings behind Dispensational theology. During those years when I was seriously trying to break into the pastoral ministry, particularly among Baptists, there remained a strong conspiratorial element of things I was warned not to discuss with average members of the flock. This particular ethic was consistently stronger around the issue of Dispensationalism. We cultivated influential volunteers to spout the orthodox line, tossing out brief lectures at every Bible study or class meeting, but it was never more critical than with the orthodoxy of Dispensational belief. That’s because it was so fragile and so easily countered. It had to be maintained at all cost, and that cost was quite high.

Dispenational theology is not a reflection of genuine faith conviction. It doesn’t feed you in quiet moments and keep you strong. It presumes an adversarial stance because the resistance is so natural. Not natural from our fallen nature, but a natural resistance because it’s so freaking insane in the first place. There’s no room for “live and let live” on this issue; it doesn’t sell itself. But it can provoke a ravenous hunger once it is pushed just a little ways among less mature souls. Dispensationalist doctrine remains one of the single biggest draws in youth ministry. Teenagers, or those who tend to operate on a juvenile level of enthusiasm, eat this up. It’s been that way since I can recall. It’s cool secret stuff that beckons with a promise of answering everything logically. It does not lend itself to calm reflection; it’s always attached to energetic urges to “do something.”

This is what keeps so many churches from contemplative religious experience.

About Ed Hurst

Disabled Veteran, prophet of God's Laws, Bible History teacher, wannabe writer, volunteer computer technician, cyclist, Social Science researcher
This entry was posted in religion and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Dispensationalism: No Rest for the Weary

  1. Old Jules says:

    Thanks for this. I’ve suspected and wondered about it for about 30 years and never got around to digging deep enough to confirm or deny my suspicions.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Iain says:

    I was suspicious of dispies from the get go. I had just prayed my own prayer acknowledging my need for redemption and forgiveness ( I wouldn’t follow the scripted “sinners prayer”). I knew in my heart that something had changed and I would never be the same. The only thing I knew I had to do was read His word, a lot.
    The first words out of the woman on my left side to the one on the right was ” we need to show him the rapture”. I was given a copy of TLGPE. I instinctively knew I should be reading the Bible but to satisfy the nuts I read Hal Lindsey’s propaganda. It seemed way out weird and I still cannot figure out why people believe this garbage. Fear? Easywayoutism? I guess that Scots Presbyterian stuff that was chunked at me when in school actually stuck. Stories of the stoic determination of the Reformation Martyrs as they faced death made me think, God didn’t spare the martyrs, what makes these people think they’ll get a pass? Is it because they’re Americans and therefore special?

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Ed Hurst says:

    Yeah, dontcha know? Americans are God’s New Chosen People. 😉

    Any Reformation-based church tends to be anti-Dispensationalist: Lutherans, Reformed, Presbyterians, etc.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Iain says:

    For penance; I shall say 100 times..
    “America is a Christian Nation” in my best John Hageese.*

    *Hageese= a sanctimonious and pompous form of English, made easier with a mouth half full of marbles.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Ed Hurst says:

    Don’t forget the engaging loud baritone.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.